Tuesday, April 27, 2010

Are you successful?

One of the most difficult things in the realm of worship leading is determining whether or not you are successful. I struggle with this on a weekly basis and I’m sure you do too. The problem is that what we do is subjective and difficult to measure. Outward expressions can be fake, emotions are fleeting and the praise of people is always tainted. So then, how do you know if you are successful?

I encourage you to set up a criteria for success. You can call them goals or vision, but it’s all basically the same. Here are some guidelines for you when setting up the basis to answer the question "are you successful?":

First of all, your criteria for success must be measurable. If it is not measurable you are subjective and will make a decision based on your perception of success or failure and possibly not the reality. This happens to me when I feel like a complete failure and that our worship experience was anything but meaningful and without fail, someone will come up to me afterwards and tell me that it was the best worship service they had ever been in. So, since emotions can be tricky, base your criteria with something measurable.

Secondly, your criteria should be meaningful. Your criteria should have a direct impact on the service or on you. Sometimes we can determine success by something that didn’t really make a difference. Since what we do can be so subjective it is easy to get in this mode where we base success on intangibles that may or may not even make a difference.

Lastly, your criteria should be spiritual and practical. Don’t just limit yourself to the spiritual side of worship leading. There is a huge practical side that makes a HUGE spiritual impact. Setting both spiritual and practical goals will help you stay balanced and effective. If we only have spiritual goals for worship we will miss out on a huge increase in our effectiveness and we will have alienated a great spiritual gift called “administration”. Something simple like having the PowerPoint slides show up at the right time is practical but greatly increases people’s ability to participate.

So make your list. Let me know what it is. How do you know if you are successful or not? Once you figure that out, communicate it with your team so that they clearly understand what your goals are. Attacking those goals as a team will help you greatly as a leader. If you are pursuing these goals all by yourself you will constantly be frustrated and feel like you are fighting your team. It’s possible that they just don’t know what your goals are. Communicate the vision and go for it! God bless.

PN

3 comments:

Steven Ganz said...

Are you going to let us know your criteria(s) for determining success?

Rob said...

Nathan,
Thanks for the article. Thought provoking as usual.

In thinking about this though, my problem is that I’m not sure what “measurable” goals there actually are in a corporate worship time that don’t turn out to be ultimately pretty superficial. I guess the general purpose of the worship team is to create an atmosphere of worship and facilitate the free move of the Holy Spirit in the participants. Neither of which can be measured specifically.

However, having said that, it does occur to me that leading worship does parallel our Christian walk to a certain extent. We are trying to die to ourselves personally, and trying to be transparent (limiting distractions) in a worship leading environment. So as you point out, getting the words up at the right time, hitting the right chords, being tight and together, choosing the right songs that flow together, etc, can all be decent measurable goals.

This would make a great live discussion I think.

Thanks again. I always enjoy reading your posts.

pastor nathan said...

@steven ganz - to be honest, they are a work in progress. I do, however, know what some of them are. Here are a few:

1. Preparation/administration
- I have to do a great job with the things I can control. It really is my choice how I prepare and if I prepare. I look at my preparation in a few different areas:
a) Prayer
1. Have a prayed over the service and prepared the way for the spirit of God to have freedom in our service?
b) Music
1. Have I memorized the music?
c) Leadership
1. Have I given the members of my team every opportunity to be successful? (i.e. do they have music in advance? Are their parts clear? Do they know what I want from them?)
2. Have I communicated clearly with them?
d) Personal Disciplines
1. Am I living a repentant life that honors God?
2. Am I consistently in the word and prayer?
3. Am I seeking God on a personal level, not solely a corporate one?

2. Have I done what my senior pastor asks?
a) I am not the captain of the ship. Even though I have a large role, my ultimate role is to submit to the leadership and direction of my pastor.

3. Removing obstacles
a) It's important for me, as the leader, to "pave the way" for people to worship God freely.
1. Do I take an aggressive approach at removing obstacles that hinder?
2. Do I train others at removing obstacles as well?
3. Am I considerate of others while still dealing with issues?

These are just a few that I've come up with so far. The problem with determining the success of a worship experience is that you can do all of this and still not feel successful or you can do none of it and God can just move powerfully. It's super weird. My point is to identify the things we can control and do them with excellence. The goal is to eliminate excuses and believe that God will do his part. :)

What do you think?